Recent Developments in Immigration

Updates from the Minister for Justice and Equality

On the 16th September 2014, Minister Fitzgerald announced new plans to increase the number of civilians carrying out key immigration functions in border management and registration roles. These jobs are currently within the purview of An Garda Siochana but as part of the Minister’s push to get more Gardai out on the streets, these roles are expected to be undertaken by an additional 80 civilian staff. The new programme will see civilians carrying out checks at both Dublin Airport terminals, as well as the transfer of the immigration permission registration function from An Garda Siochana to the Irish Naturalisation and Immigration Service of the Department of Justice and Equality (INIS). The Minister noted that the Gardai “will continue to provide core policing functions at the Airport and support the civilian staff as appropriate”. The full text of the Minister’s press release can be found at: <http://www.inis.gov.ie/en/INIS/Pages/Minister%20Fitzgerald%20announces%20major%20immigration%20civilianisation%20initiative>

On the 2nd September 2014, the Minister announced major reforms of the student immigration and international education sector. This move comes in the wake of a number of private college closures this year. The reforms aim to protect the interests of genuine students, while reducing instances whereby the immigration system can be abused. A recent policy statement sets out three primary pillars of reform: only accredited programmes will be in a position to enrol international students, inspection will be increased to ensure education and immigration standards are maintained, and the non-EEA student work concession will be altered to mitigate abuse. In the course of her statement, Minister Fitzgerald also warned those students affected by college closures earlier in 2014 to regularise their status in the State and ensure they were abiding by current immigration laws. The full text of the Minister’s press release, along with links to the policy statement of the Task Force, can be found at: <http://www.inis.gov.ie/en/INIS/Pages/Ministers%20O%E2%80%99Sullivan%20and%20Fitzgerald%20launch%20major%20reform%20of%20student%20immigration%20and%20the%20international%20education%20sector>

Proposed reforms of Direct Provision Centres

Following increased media reportage into conditions in the State’s Direct Provision centres, in mid-August the Minister for Justice announced that a working group was to be established in the coming month to review the current system. The main issues outlined by the Minister include welfare payments, third-level education access, and support for children. Although Minister Fitzgerald has promised a more efficient application process would be in place by midway through 2015, she also ruled out the possibility of an absolute extension of the right to work to asylum seekers, citing the country’s unemployment issues as cause. While the establishment of a working group has been praised as a positive development by UN agencies, in more recent days that Minister has warned against “unrealistic expectations” in terms of reform. At present some 4,330 adults and children are being housed in Direct Provision centres around the country. Pressure is mounting on the Government to improve living standards, with recent weeks seeing asylum seekers protesting the system and calling for an end to Direct Provision entirely. Full articles on the above can be found at: The Irish Times “Government to review conditions for asylum seekers” 12th August 2014 <http://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/government-to-review-conditions-for-asylum-seekers-1.1894079> The Irish Times “Minister warns against unrealistic expectations on direct provison” 25th September 2014 <http://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/oireachtas/minister-warns-against-unrealistic-expectations-on-direct-provision-1.1940425> The Irish Times “Asylum seekers mount protest at Cork direct provision centre” 15th September 2014 <http://www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/asylum-seekers-mount-protest-at-cork-direct-provision-centre-1.1929294>

Immigration, Residence and Protection Bill 2010

As part of her pledge to speed up the asylum process in the coming year, Minister Fitzgerald has committed to the introduction of a Single Procedure Mechanism, as distinct from the provisions of the currently dormant Immigration, Residence and Protection Bill. The Single Procedure Mechanism would allow claims for asylum and subsidiary protection to be made simultaneously. At present, claimants must first seek asylum, regardless of whether they meet the stringent criteria for refugee status. This procedure could theoretically save claimants years of waiting, and has been campaigned for by numerous organisations including the Irish Refugee Council and NASC. Publications and press releases on the above can be found at: “Press release: NASC welcomes renewed government commitment to reform of direct provision” 12 August 2014 <http://www.nascireland.org/latest-news/press-release-nasc-welcomes-renewed-government-commitment-reform-direct-provision/> “Roadmap for Asylum Reform” < http://irc.fusio.net/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Roadmap-for-Asylum-Reform2.pdf> 


Brophy Solicitors

CASE STUDY – SOMALI ASYLUM SEEKERS AND DILEMMA FACING DECISION MAKERS - QFC, AMC v RAT, MJELR, (2012) IEHC 4

Justice Cooke recently granted leave to seek a judicial review in respect of a negative asylum decision on the basis of the decision maker’s failure to assess the possibility of future persecution open to asylum seekers if returned to Somalia.  Asylum was refused to the Applicant as result of credibility findings but Justice Cooke noted the dilemma that faces decision makers in cases where credibility issues arise but the applicant is also from an undeniably dangerous country. 

Justice Cooke held that, “any decision maker faced with a claim for asylum based upon a risk of persecution of any applicant who is accepted as being from Somalia must proceed with extreme caution and must reject a claim upon grounds of lack of personal credibility only when it is compellingly necessary to do so.”

The judge held that the fact that the Applicant had a child with a man who was not her husband could lead to persecution if she was returned to Somalia. The lack of credibility with regard to past persecution did not exclude the possibility of future persecution. He held that “the particular story told by the asylum seeker may correctly be disbelieved but it may yet be important to examine the possibility that the person in question may nevertheless have a valid Convention based reason for being unable or unwilling to return to the country of origin especially where it is known to be a place of internal conflict or of prevalent violence.”  

You can read the full judgement here.

2011 Immigration Figures Released as Minister Looks Ahead to 2012

Ireland saw a sharp decline in the numbers of asylum seekers entering the country in 2011. Only 1250 people claimed asylum here last year, just 1/10 of the peak figure of 11,600 in 2002.

The decrease in figures has been attributed to increased control measures. These most recent figures are the ninth successive fall in numbers claiming asylum since its highest point ten years ago. But also relevant in the economic downturn as Ireland’s attraction as a desirable destination point wanes.

Minster Shatter announced the figures in a press release yesterday. Alongside statistics  for 2011 came welcome news for those involved in other immigration processes. A clear statement on policy in regards Family Reunification is promised. Also a six-month processing time can be expected for all standard citizenship application from this Spring onwards.

Other measures will include the implementation of an Immigrant Investor Programme, a start up Entrepreneur Programme for Immigrants, a review of the operation of the Pilot Visa Programme, implementation of a Civilianisation officer pilot programme at Dublin Airport, to be launched this month, and completion of work on the development of an English language/Civics test for naturalisation applicants. 

Minister Shatter also detailed that 2012 would see the department looking across the water: ‘In particular, the promotion of the Visa Waiver Programme in the context of the London Olympics will be a key priority with the aim of boosting tourism and visitors to Ireland. Similarly, new initiatives targeted at immigrant investors and entrepreneurs will be prioritised with the purpose of attracting inward investment and job creation.’


Minister Shatter's full statement is available here. 


Brophy Solicitors 
04.01.12 

ZAMBRANO: STAMP 4 AND EDUCATIONAL SUPPORT

We contacted the Department of Justice and Equality recently in respect of a number of queries raised regarding entitlements to education support for non nationals resident on Stamp 4 Status.

Many persons residing in Ireland are eligible for an ‘Immigration Stamp 4’ which, according to the Minister’s Office, entitles the holder to work without need for an employment permit but does not confer an entitlement to any particular public service or funding as such matters are determined by the relevant government departments or State agencies.   One of our clients has been granted a Stamp 4 for one year based on discretionary Humanitarian Leave to Remain.  She is also the mother of an Irish citizen child and wants to apply for a Stamp 4 pursuant to Zambrano as the policy operating from the Department generally provides for a Stamp 4 for three years. She intends to enrol in a Third Level Education Scheme under which she will be eligible for free fees based on her current status in the State.  However, the eligible categories of stamp holders entitled to avail of such a scheme do not yet specifically cover ‘Zambrano’ type Stamp 4 holders. 

We contacted the State in an attempt to ascertain information on whether or not our client would be entitled to continue to be eligible to avail of free fees under Stamp 4 (Zambrano).  The Minister advised that the Department has no function in matters relating to educational supports and that this issue will be a matter for the Department of Education and Skills.

We have however been informed that the Department of Justice and Equality has set up a dedicated email enquiry database under which education grant awarding bodies can submit queries in relation to the immigration status of their applicants.  Such information is not entirely useful to our client but it would be worth contacting the Department of Education and Skills if you are concerned that your stamp might not entitle you to access educational support. 

We believe that persons who have been granted permission to remain in Ireland to care and support their Irish citizen children, should not be treated any less favourably in terms of accessing services or public funding in respect of education, than those who have been granted permission to remain on humanitarian grounds. There is potential for great confusion as to the type of residency permission that is conferred on a person who is entitled to reside in the State pursuant to Zambrano, a decision that issued from the ECJ relying wholly on the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. 

Brophy Solicitors

18.11.11