Friday, August 23, 2013

Naturalisation Rates in Ireland Amongst the Lowest in Europe

According to recent research Ireland has the second lowest rate in granting naturalisation applications in the EU at just 13%. Despite a citizenship regime which is theoretically more inclusive than many other EU states, only Luxembourg has a lower rate and the average rate across the EU (34%) is over two times higher than in Ireland.

In 2008, the Immigrant Council of Ireland published research that highlighted the fundamental extent to which immigration status affects people’s ability to make longer-term plans, participate in Irish society and, ultimately, their successful integration. This point was emphasised in connection with the importance of naturalisation and citizenship for immigrants in the Council’s 2011 ‘Living in Limbo’ report which called for changes to the naturalisation application process to simplify and speed up the process for those who wanted to obtain Irish citizenship.

This year’s report, published by the Migration Policy Group in Brussels, identified several barriers to Irish citizenship for applicants such as the lack guidelines for applicants and lack of clarity and transparency in light of the Minister for Justice and Equality’s absolute discretion regarding citizenship applications. This lack of transparency is worsened by the lack of a formal appeals system and the lack of reasons given in cases of a refusal. The report also notes that the Irish system is one of the most demanding in terms of documentation requirements and also has higher application costs than most other EU countries. Furthermore, despite a commitment by the Minister for Justice in 2011 to reduce waiting times for applicants to 6 months many applications are still taking over a year to complete.

Chief Executive of the Immigrant Council of Ireland, Denise Charlton, said that Ireland’s low rate of citizenship has economic and social implications for Ireland, noting that immigrants who have been naturalised find it easier to integrate with Irish society and “are more often employed, less often overqualified for their jobs, have better housing conditions and have less difficulty paying household expenses.”

Freya Foster

Friday, August 16, 2013

Domestic violence and immigration law issues brought before Oireachtas Justice Committee

The Immigrant Council of Ireland, as part of the Domestic Violence Coalition, has called on the Government to introduce new laws formally recognising the issue of domestic violence in Irish immigration law. Approximately 10% of the Immigrant Council’s overall caseload involved domestic violence however the Council noted in its submission to the Oireachtas Justice Committee that many victims may not be coming forward for fear that it could impact on their right to remain in Ireland. This fear, coupled with administrative barriers and lack of access to safe emergency housing, can leave people vulnerable to threats, abuse and violence.

In addition to legislative action, the Council called for short term measures to be taken in the form of a coordinated administrative response by the Irish Naturalisation and Immigration Service, the Department of Social Protection and the Health Service Executive. It also welcomed a policy clarification issued by INIS in 2012 regarding the possibility of applying for an independent residency permit for non-EEA nationals who are experiencing domestic violence.

However the Council noted the shortfalls of this guidance, namely its reliance on discretion and the lack of clarity as to what type of status would be granted or the likely processing time for the application. It also cautioned that the €300 fee required for a Garda National Immigration Bureau certificate of registration that is paid after a successful application, was a serious barrier to applicants since many would previously have been financially dependant on their abuser and would therefore struggle to pay the fee. The Council emphasised the importance of continuing social welfare payments for eligible non-EEA victims of domestic violence regardless of the stage of their immigration application and regardless of their current immigration status.

The Council also suggested that the UK experience of introducing and refining a domestic violence concession could provide useful guidance in both the legislative and administrative context. This includes a wide definition of domestic violence, equal application to male and female partners, married and unmarried couples and to opposite and same sex relationships. Fee exemptions, legal aid and flexibility regarding evidentiary requirements were also suggested. Importantly being undocumented should not prohibit making an application as the time taken to appreciate or be advised that there is a remedy available may mean that leave has expired in many cases.

In their submissions the Council also urged the Irish government to sign and ratify the Council Of Europe 2011 Convention on Combating and Preventing Violence against Women and Domestic Violence which has already been signed by 26 members of the Council of Europe. 

Freya Foster

Friday, August 9, 2013

Changes to Immigrant Investor Programme introduced

Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence, Mr Alan Shatter TD, recently announced changes to the Department’s Immigrant Investor Programme. The scheme is designed to encourage foreign investment and offers residency rights to individuals from outside the EU who have a high net worth. These residency rights are offered in exchange for certain levels of investment in Irish businesses, in Government Bonds, in property (along with bonds) or by way of endowments. 

Since its launch last year, nine applications under the Immigrant Investor Programme have been approved. However Minister Shatter noted that more could be done to attract foreign investment under this scheme. The changes, which took effect on the 15th of July, include a reduction of 50% in the minimum investment for both Government bonds (decreased to €1 million) and Irish businesses (decreased to €500,000). The changes will add payment of education fees for the children of investors as contributions to the level of investment required under the scheme. These changes mean that persons can now avail of the programmes benefits (residency rights in Ireland) with lower levels of investment.

The scheme will be promoted through Ireland’s embassy network and the State agencies involved in the promotion of trade investment and enterprise. Minister Shatter concluded his announcement of the changes by noting that "Ireland is an excellent place to do business and has many advantages in terms of its quality of life for investors and their families. They are very welcome here and will find good business opportunities….[The Immigrant Investor Programme] is a further indication of the Government’s recognition of the role that talented and successful migrants can make to Ireland’s economic development and the contribution they can make to job creation."

Freya Foster

Friday, August 2, 2013

RECOGNITION OF STATELESSNESS IN IRELAND

In Ireland, there is no procedure for the determination and recognition of a person’s status as stateless, despite the fact that Ireland is a party to both the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness.


The UNHCR Irish office has highlighted this failing in the Irish Immigration system, and it is stated as follows on their website



“UNHCR has noted that, in Ireland there is currently no discrete procedure in which a stateless person can have their status considered. The absence of identification impacts on a stateless persons’ ability to get, for instance, travel documents, and to make representations to the Minister to waive the naturalization requirements as specified in Section 16 (g) of the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act 1956 (as amended).



UNHCR is currently working with the Irish authorities to see how statelessness identification procedures might be introduced in Ireland.”


It is surprising that the Irish State appears to recognize statelessness in one very narrow respect – applications for Naturalization. Section 16 (g) of the Nationality and Citizenship Act 1956 (as amended) provides the Minister for Justice and Equality, the discretion to waive the normal conditions for naturalization for both refugees and Stateless persons. It is strange that stateless persons can apply for such a benefit where they cannot officially apply to the State to have their stateless status recognized. 

It is also surprising that to the Travel Document Section of the INIS website indicates the Minister’s policy in issuing travel documents to stateless persons as follows;

“The State (Irish Naturalisation & Immigration Service) is obliged to issue travel documents to persons granted protection in accordance with:
  • The 1951 UN Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (Article 28) and The Refugee Act, 1996 (Article 4)
  • The 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons (Article 28)
  • The European Communities (Eligibility for Protection) Regulations 2006 (SI 518 of 2006)”

However, it is impossible to obtain such a stateless Travel Document in Ireland, because no person can currently obtain recognition of their stateless status. 

We have recently issued High Court proceedings seeking a declaration that the Minister’s failure to have in place a transparent and effective system by which our client can apply for and obtain a declaration of statelessness and a 1954 Convention Travel Document constitutes a breach of the our client’s right to the effective exercise of his legal rights under European Union law, the Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights Act 2003. 

Until the Minster has set up a fair process for the determination and recognition of stateless persons, we suggest that all stateless persons resident in the State should write to the Minister for Justice, to make the following requests ;
  1. Request the Minister to acknowledge your status as a stateless person by way of a Certificate of Statelessness
  2. Request that the Minister provide you with a Travel Document pursuant to the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons
  3. Request the Minister to explain why no mechanism has been put in place to acknowledge your status as stateless, despite Ireland being a party to the Conventions on Statelessness 
  4. Request the Minister to explain if and when such a mechanism will be put in place.